Cars & Trucks Logo
Posted on Mar 30, 2017
Answered by a Fixya Expert

Trustworthy Expert Solutions

At Fixya.com, our trusted experts are meticulously vetted and possess extensive experience in their respective fields. Backed by a community of knowledgeable professionals, our platform ensures that the solutions provided are thoroughly researched and validated.

View Our Top Experts

Persistent 'Battery / Alternator' Fault

First off, the car wouldn't start and reported a 'battery/alternator' fault - applied a jump starter to the terminals, nothing. It was trailered into the main dealer and they replaced earth leads and it worked - for a day. Next day battery ran out of juice on way to work - but would restart and work with a jumper pack on the battery terminals - recovered again to main dealer. Main dealer replaced alternator - car worked, for a week. Now car refused to start - back to same symptoms as first time - about to be recovered for a third time. I'd like to replace the main dealer's strategy of randomly replacing modules at my expense until they accidentally get it right - any advice appreciated.

  • gadget153 Jan 24, 2009

    Sorry - neglected to say the vehicle is a 2000 Mercedes Benz E320 CDI Estate

×

1 Answer

montehammons

Level 3:

An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

Superstar:

An expert that got 20 achievements.

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

  • Mercedes-Benz Master 5,531 Answers
  • Posted on Mar 30, 2017
montehammons
Mercedes-Benz Master
Level 3:

An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

Superstar:

An expert that got 20 achievements.

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Joined: Sep 14, 2011
Answers
5531
Questions
2
Helped
1643281
Points
17401

Alternators are expensive parts, especially at dealerships. I'm inclined to agree with you, they should have got it right the first time. No shortage of tools with them, but in fairness to them, intermittent faults are the hardest to detect.
They might come back and say you need a new battery, although it does seem odd that a little testing the first time might have caught that.
Those are the two main items in the start circuit you are having trouble with. Well, the battery, the alternator, the starter and the ignition switch, those four items are the main parts of the start circuit. But with a good battery and an alternator to keep the battery charged up, it will crank over every time. Ideally, that means it will start and run.

5 Related Answers

Anonymous

  • 19 Answers
  • Posted on Nov 13, 2008

SOURCE: HELP HELP !!!!!!! Electric fault i think !!!!!!!!!!

1....ensure the battery in the "Key Fob" is OK............Press either Lock or Unlock button for more than 1 second, the lamp on the fob will light if OK. Change battery if it does not illuminate! 2.....if battery on fob OK.......Re Syncronise the key fob to the car by:.... a brief press on either button twice and within 30 seconds turn Key to position 2 on the ignition lock
Hope that fixes it...let me know?

Ad

Anonymous

  • 62 Answers
  • Posted on Dec 29, 2008

SOURCE: battery keeps dying on 2001 c 240

YOU PROBALLY HAVE A NEGATIVE POWER DRAW TO CHECK THIS USE A TESTER LIGHT AND CLIP THE WIRE TO THE POSITIVE SIDE OF BATTERY AND TOUCH THE NEGATIVE BATTERY TERMINAL IF IT LIGHTS UP U HAVE A NEGATIVE POWER DRAW

Anonymous

  • 14 Answers
  • Posted on Mar 02, 2009

SOURCE: 2000 Mercedes-Benz Mercedes Benz E320 Cdi Automatic

have yor dealer check for updated software for your transmission or engine control modules

co7196

Ned C Cook

  • 3433 Answers
  • Posted on May 27, 2009

SOURCE: the car won't start in the morning

Let's test the battery. Turn on yout headlights ant try to crank engine.
If the headlights dim, the battery is dead. If the headlightd go out you have a bag connection.
Now if the battery is dead we need to start it to ck the charging ststem.
If the indicarion is a bad connection then the battery cables beed removing clean and tight reinstsllation( special attento both ends of boyj cables.
To ck altrnator engine must be running and uou need a 10 dollar multimer from a parts stor and then get back to me K?

Anonymous

  • 3 Answers
  • Posted on Aug 17, 2009

SOURCE: Dead battery. Alternator is charging, but the

check the fuse box, fuse #19 -

Ad

Add Your Answer

×

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

0helpful
2answers

My 2007 dodge caliber wont start even after its been jumped by another car. could this be a dead battery or alternator or maybe my starter

Could be the battery has a short and won't allow full amps during the jump to start the car. Change out the battery and give it a try.
1helpful
1answer

I have a 2001 1.4 polo playa. It started fine and the following morning nothing. The starter doesnt turn over and does nothing when you turn it, help pls. The battery is fine

If the battery is fine , then it will either be a faulty starter motor or a problem with the ignition switch, did you have the battery checked for Amperage ? if you just were able to power the lights etc this could still mean the battery isn't holding enough charge, another reason for a battery fault would be the alternator not charging at the correct rate, especially at night when using lights, heater if cold , all these will take charge away from battery if alternator fault/drive belt to loose .Have you tried to jump start the vehicle , if it starts with a jump start then definately a problem with the battery/charging system, hope this helps
0helpful
2answers

Battery light flashing jump it ,it will start but not run

It could be you have a fault in the Diode pack in the alternator you need to get this checked at an alternator repair center.
0helpful
1answer

Had my alternator rebuilt, but batteries still go dead.checked alternator shows charging at 11.9 volts then jumps to 15 volts after 2 minutes. is this the alternator

The alternator should be showing at least 15 volts when running! Anything lower would indicate the alternator is at fault, since you say it is showing below 12 volts even for 2 minutes indicates a fault.

there still could be a fault with the battery not holding its charge or something draining the battery like a wire shorting or trunk light staying on that is making the battery go flat!
0helpful
1answer

Battery, alternator, and starter check good. Car needs to be jump started, but then is dead when turned off.

hi there. you might have a fault on your electrical system draining your
battery. short out.
1helpful
1answer

All I get is clicks when trying to start my 2004 Taurus se. I had the starter ckecked at o'reilly's and it was good. In order to start I have to jump it from starter. Please help.

U may deal a low battery condition,as the jump worked on ur starter.
Ceck recharge alternator rate (alternator condition belt,plugs,ussualy gets a red worning on dash low charge rate)
.Ceck battery level(if apply)/clean connectors.Replace battery if ended.
Ceck for over draining condition (shortcircuit,lights/radio left on)
cheers,let us know if figured out.
0helpful
1answer

Alternator/battery fault

if it wont run with jump leads on, probably means your battery has failed. replace the battery
0helpful
2answers

I have a 1997 Ford taurus GL. Decided not to start a few days ago so bought a new battery. Ran okay for a couple of days then wouldn't start, but did so with a jump. Now jumping it does nothing and...

It's the alternator...it is not keeping your battery charged. You can remove it and take it to a local parts store and they will test it for free.
1helpful
1answer

Accord seems to be draining power overnight. only a fast clicking sound when attempting to start. battery 6 months old.

hi, it seems you have a fault DISCHARGE OF BATTERY: make sure there is no lights left ON vehicle inside or out, if phone charger left ON the fast clicking is the starter motor solinoid triing to connect to the starter motor NOT ENOUGH CURRENT TO START ENGINE, sometimes the alternator can have a slight fault, water driping on the contacts on the alternator will flatten the battery, (this is a DIRECT CONNECTION TO THE STARTER MOTOR and BATTERY). naturally the clock, radio, alarm system, all these sytem reduce the battery but this is NOT THE FAULT. charge the battery again it may be just this once. gerry
0helpful
1answer

Engine wont turn over, but with a jump it starts battery holds a charge and the alternator light does not come on when engine is running indicating a fault what can it be

#1 Clean your Battery Post's and Battery Cable Connections with a Metal Battery Cleaner Brush.
Make sure the Battery Cables are tightened enough.
I just did my neighbor's van and that was the only problem prohibiting it from starting. It was also inhibiting a proper recharge of the battery from the alternator.
#2 When "jumping": was it Post to Post or Negative to Engine Block and Positive to Post? If so then check your Ground wire going to the Engine Block. Remove and using a metal brush - clean both the wire and the connection spot.
#3 What Fault Code is showing?
#4 Starter Relay possibly faulty. However starting with a "jump" all but rules this out. It again points back the Battery.
#5 Battery may be holding a charge, however whats is the Voltage? Below 10.5 and there is not enough power to Start the vehicle.
Let me know if this helped, or if you have any additional information or questions. Feel free to contact me at FixYa.com!
Not finding what you are looking for?

320 views

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Mercedes-Benz Experts

ZJ Limited
ZJ Limited

Level 3 Expert

17989 Answers

Ronny Bennett Sr.
Ronny Bennett Sr.

Level 3 Expert

6988 Answers

xxxxxx xxx

Level 3 Expert

5117 Answers

Are you a Mercedes-Benz Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...