Cars & Trucks Logo

Related Topics:

Frank Duchon Posted on Nov 17, 2012
Answered by a Fixya Expert

Trustworthy Expert Solutions

At Fixya.com, our trusted experts are meticulously vetted and possess extensive experience in their respective fields. Backed by a community of knowledgeable professionals, our platform ensures that the solutions provided are thoroughly researched and validated.

View Our Top Experts

I have a 98 BMW 328i with a manual 5-speed transmission. One day I get in the car and noticed it was hard to shift into gears the clutch felt good and car would drive normal just stiff to put into gears and grinds when I shift into reverse. Would this be a clutch or transmission problem?

1 Answer

Jamie Alton

Level 3:

An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

Top Expert:

An expert who has finished #1 on the weekly Top 10 Fixya Experts Leaderboard.

Superstar:

An expert that got 20 achievements.

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

  • Cars & Trucks Master 1,007 Answers
  • Posted on Nov 17, 2012
Jamie Alton
Cars & Trucks Master
Level 3:

An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

Top Expert:

An expert who has finished #1 on the weekly Top 10 Fixya Experts Leaderboard.

Superstar:

An expert that got 20 achievements.

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

Joined: Oct 30, 2012
Answers
1007
Questions
0
Helped
273098
Points
2955

It could be typically due to one or two things:

1) The clutch plate is sticking on the gearbox splines due to build up of corrosion or lack of lubrication. May happen especially after long standing with no operation.

2) Gearbox oil is old and requires replacement.

3) Clutch operation requires adjustment or repair. Check clutch fluid or cable condition and operation.

5 Related Answers

Anonymous

  • 1586 Answers
  • Posted on Aug 12, 2008

SOURCE: Reverse gear has grinding noise...?

Have them flush the fluid out under warranty and put in new fluid, and have them bleed the clutch lines in case air is getting in there. Audi and VW claim lifetime transmission fluid but it's BS - I've changed relatively low mile fluid from these cars and it was horrendous. It's possible that the fluid itself is causing trouble, but it's more likely that it is a synchro problem. If it was a clutch issue, you should have problems with more than just reverse gear - a clutch simply engages and disengages the engine and transmission, regardless of which gear it is. The problem (if not fixed by fluid) is in the transmission, and being under warranty, don't accept another "suggestion" like they're giving you. Changing your clutch isn't gonna do it.

Ad
emissionwiz

Marvin

  • 85242 Answers
  • Posted on Oct 31, 2008

SOURCE: transmision shifting problem

Reverse is not sycronized, this means the gears have to stop to mess and not grind, two thing cause this, being to quick to slam into reverse after clutch is depressed, a problem with the clutch.

Anonymous

  • 95 Answers
  • Posted on Mar 30, 2009

SOURCE: My 98 Escort ZX2 manual transmisson seems to shift gear hard!

Clutch may be smooth but this is a sign of the clutch needing replaced. Some of these models have a linkage adjustment under the hood. Others are hydrallic and need fluid. Look under the hood where the steering is and see which you have and address accordingly. Good luck. Check on costs of clutch replacement.

nathan

  • 634 Answers
  • Posted on Jul 08, 2009

SOURCE: my 98 cavalier manual stick shift will not go to reverse gear

sounds like the shifter linkage has worn and not working properly need to lift in air and inspect the linkage

Anonymous

  • 11 Answers
  • Posted on Aug 17, 2009

SOURCE: Mazda 626 - Hard to shift into gear.

With any vehicle that has a hydraulic clutch, a worn master cylinder or slave cylinder will give this very symptom. First step is to check the fluid in the resivor. If it is low, you will want to check for fluid bypassing the seals. Be sure to check under the rubber dust cover as fluid can collect there and not be readily visible. Also, if the fluid in the resivor is dark colored, it is an indication of the internal seals going bad and you will need to replace the cylinders.

Ad

Add Your Answer

×

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

1helpful
1answer

I have a 2009 Chevy Daewoo Avero 5-speed standard change the clutch in it and now it won't go into reverse

When the clutch was changed, the gear shift linkage would have been disconnected so the transmission could be removed. If it wasn't put back together properly, or had worn parts that weren't noticed at the time, that could be the problem. I once had a Chevrolet Citation (look that up!) with a 4-speed manual transmission, and one day it wouldn't shift into reverse. The linkage was loose, and a fairly easy fix.
0helpful
1answer

1994 FORD F150 5 SPEED MAZDA MANUAL TRANSMISSION SHIFTS INTO ALL GEARS BUT REVERSE



99 00 01 02 03 FORD F150 MANUAL TRANSMISSION 5 SPEED MAZDA-TOYO KOGYO 4X2 8 CYL

will it shift if you double clutch ?

might be a shift linkage adjustment
internal shift fork has broken a scroll pin

clutch fork movement ok ?


26339849-agxp3ilddhhnij2ev2hgkhsv-4-0.jpg
0helpful
1answer

What causes hard sticky shifting on 5-speed manual transmission. The manual transmission was almost 1/2 quart low when I changed the gear oil.

If the shift lever is what is hard & sticky, get some grease & lube the handle at the joint at the trans. ( Maint. anyway) . The right gear oil? Was it doing it before the oil chg ? How's the clutch feel? Clutch, Pressure plate & throw out bearing poss. Smell any burning smells? One step at a time. Good luck
1helpful
1answer

I have a 1999 328i with 135k on it, the other day

have you found a cure? i have the same nasty problem...... please help =[
0helpful
1answer

Hard to shift 5 speed manual speed transmission on 1995 rodeo

pending on the type of clutch in the vehicle, you may be low on clutch fluid. (if your clutch is hydraulic)
other than that it is most likely the entire clutch itself.
2helpful
1answer

My 98 Escort ZX2 manual transmisson seems to shift gear hard!

Clutch may be smooth but this is a sign of the clutch needing replaced. Some of these models have a linkage adjustment under the hood. Others are hydrallic and need fluid. Look under the hood where the steering is and see which you have and address accordingly. Good luck. Check on costs of clutch replacement.
6helpful
3answers

TRANSMISSION 2nd to 3rd GEAR HARDSHIFT

  1. the automatic transmission for bmw 328i 1997 move to front to rear
1helpful
3answers

1998 tiburon 5 speed manuaL transmission

hey
try to use quaker state synthetic bleed multi vehicle atf
Not finding what you are looking for?

603 views

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Cars & Trucks Experts

ZJ Limited
ZJ Limited

Level 3 Expert

17989 Answers

john h

Level 3 Expert

29494 Answers

Arnie Burke
Arnie Burke

Level 3 Expert

7339 Answers

Are you a Car and Truck Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...