1999 Saturn SL Logo
Posted on Sep 23, 2008
Answered by a Fixya Expert

Trustworthy Expert Solutions

At Fixya.com, our trusted experts are meticulously vetted and possess extensive experience in their respective fields. Backed by a community of knowledgeable professionals, our platform ensures that the solutions provided are thoroughly researched and validated.

View Our Top Experts

EGR Valve, O2 Sensor

Ok, so my engine light came on awhile ago. Diagnostic said it was a problem with my 02 sensor. I drove with it for awhile (2-3 months) knowing that a faulty 02 sensor wouldn't kill me. Recently I replaced it. I went into the shop to have my codes reset and there was 3 O2 codes and one EGR code. I thought that possibly the O2 sensor being broken was the reason the EGR code was triggered and with a new 02 sensor, I would be fine. The engine light stayed off for a few days but came back on. Now it's saying I have an issue with my EGR valve. Do I need to replace it, or clean it, or is this an electrical problem? What is my best bet here in solving this issue? Also, will a faulty EGR valve cause my gas mileage to be very poor and cause other performance issues with my car?

3 Answers

Anonymous

Level 1:

An expert who has achieved level 1.

Mayor:

An expert whose answer got voted for 2 times.

  • Contributor 1 Answer
  • Posted on Jun 06, 2009
Anonymous
Contributor
Level 1:

An expert who has achieved level 1.

Mayor:

An expert whose answer got voted for 2 times.

Joined: Jun 06, 2009
Answers
1
Questions
0
Helped
3050
Points
7

Absolutely a bad o2 sensor can cause problems with performance. If you replace one it is highly recommended to replace both or all four depending on your vehicle. If one o2 sensor is making your vehicle run rich you will burn more fuel and in return increase the amount of carbon or unburnt fuel if you will in your egr valve you could probably get away with cleaning it but I would recommend replacing it, it will save you from having to pull it off again. Check your catyletic converter because long exposure to carbon will mess it up.

Anonymous

Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Governor:

An expert whose answer got voted for 20 times.

New Friend:

An expert that has 1 follower.

  • Expert 73 Answers
  • Posted on Sep 24, 2008
Anonymous
Expert
Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Governor:

An expert whose answer got voted for 20 times.

New Friend:

An expert that has 1 follower.

Joined: Sep 09, 2008
Answers
73
Questions
0
Helped
41026
Points
221

Yes a bad egr valve can cause rough idle. Most of the time the egr valves stick on that model. If you take the egr valve off and turn it over you will see a small opening and a pintle which looks like a torx head bolt. Try pushing on the bolt and most of the time a faulty one will stick open. It sould move freely. On those there is no way of cleaning them you just replace them. Hope this helps.

Ad

Anonymous

Level 1:

An expert who has achieved level 1.

Problem Solver:

An expert who has answered 5 questions.

  • Contributor 6 Answers
  • Posted on Feb 26, 2009
Anonymous
Contributor
Level 1:

An expert who has achieved level 1.

Problem Solver:

An expert who has answered 5 questions.

Joined: Feb 26, 2009
Answers
6
Questions
0
Helped
5976
Points
9

I had the same problem, and I must disagree, I removed it and used choke/carb cleaner and screw drivers plus a little O-ring pick set of like hooked and sharper tools to scrape it clean and spray it, and scrape it and so forth. She is back to driving like a champ. i have a 1999 Saturn SL2 Manual. I am making a youtube video of the fix, I'll post its link when its up. 

Add Your Answer

×

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

0helpful
2answers
1helpful
1answer

Engine Service Soon Light On code P0154

Error Code: P0154
Description:
Heated Oxygen Sensor (HO2S) 1 , Bank 2 - No Activity Detected
Problem areas:
- Wiring.
- Open circuit in signal wire, between Heated Oxygen sensor 1, Bank 2 and ECM. (Must check and confirm)
- Heated oxygen sensor (HO2S).
- Engine control module (ECM).
1helpful
1answer

Tune up code 2196 what is this?

P2195 is 02 sensor stuck lean ( bank 1 sensor 1 )--check for a possible vacuum leak in all vacuum lines.-- if no vacuum or other leaks could be egr valve. p2196 is the same but stuck rich,p0053 is ho2 sensor bank 1 sensor 1 heater resister all codes are related to the o2 sensor, p0113 is intake air tempurature curcuit high input ( IAT ). check wiring or senser replace if need be. if you can not find any leaks and egr system is ok, then its the 02 sensor causeing this.
0helpful
1answer

Found a crack in the exhaust manifold

transmission solenoid and misfire code unrelated
but need looking into
02 sensor should be fixed with replaced 02 sensor
egr code only if crack is close by


cast iron zorst manifolds
if the crack takes up when engine is running
not urgent
when ready source
a used manifold without a crack from a wrecker
cracks in cast iron zorst manifolds cant be welded
sucessfuly

or buy (extractors )metal exhaust manifold
if they crack... they can be welded
3helpful
1answer

Hi 2005 ford freestar engine light is on bought code scanner and was given these codes....p2195, p2196, p0053, p0132 and p0133 i also bought the shop service manual from the dealer..however, ididnt...

p2195 is 02 sensor stuck lean ( bank 1 sensor 1 )--check for a possible vacuum leak in all vacuum lines.-- if no vacuum or other leaks could be egr valve. p2196 is the same but stuck rich,--p0053 is ho2 sensor bank 1 sensor 1 heater resister all codes are related to the o2 sensor, p0113 is intake air tempurature curcuit high input ( IAT ). check wiring or senser replace if need be. if you can not find any leaks and egr system is ok, then its the 02 sensor causeing this.
1helpful
3answers

Check engine light on

Diagnostic Trouble Codes OBD1
Mazda 02 Crank Position Sensor (NE Signal). 03 Cam Position Sensor (SGC Signal). 05 Knock Sensor. 08 Air Flow Sensor. 09 Engine Coolant Temperature Sensor. 10 Intake Air Temp. Sensor (Air Flow Sensor). 12 Throttle Position Sensor. 14 Barometric Absolute Press. Sensor. 15
and/or
23 Heated Oxygen Sensor (Inactivation). 16 EGR Function Sensor. 25 Pressure Regulator Control Solenoid Valve. 26 Purge Control Solenoid Valve. 28 EGR Vacuum Solenoid Valve. 29 EGR Vent Solenoid Valve. 34 Idle Air Control Valve. 41 VRIS 1 Solenoid Valve. 46 VRIS 2 Solenoid Valve.
16helpful
2answers

Will not pass emissions code p0401 infuficient egr flow

EGR flow is monitored by the PCM by it looking for a reaction in the FRONT O2 sensor in responce to the command given to the EGR valve. The linear electronic EGR valve sends a return signal to the PCM indicating the relative position of the step motor and hence how far open (or closed) the EGR valve is in responce to the PCM command. The PCM expects to see (within a set of given parameters) a change in the O2 sensor reading (change in exhaust gas make up) after the EGR valve is commanded open or closed. If it doesn't, or that change is not within the expected parameters, a code will be set based on the skewed data. Generally a "insufficient flow" code will be set by:

1.Faulty EGR valve (sticking, or "lying" to the PCM about the actual valve position)
2.Faulty electrical connection at the EGR valve (causing false data)
3.Clogged EGR passages
4. Bad read from the MAP, or TPS, causing the PCM to misinterpret the EGR data based on faulty operational data from the other sensors
5. (Very rarely) A marginally "slow" O2 sensor. (PCM does not "see" the change in exhaust make up quick enough and interprets that as poor EGR flow.)
I have found that normally this code means that the EGR is not opening the amount that it has been commaneded to by the PCM. Normal cure for me lately has beed to repalce the EGR valve and to clean out the passages while the valve is off. The Tech 2 is able to command the EGR open and show the commanded opening and the actual opening. When this code is present the actual and commanded do not match closely at all. Thanks for using FixYa - a FixYa rating is appreciated for taking the time to answer your FREE question.
1helpful
1answer

90 chevy 5.7L k1500 failed emissions

COULD BE A VACUUM LEAK TAKE PROPANE TORCH AND LEAVE OFF PUT AROUND ALL VACUUM POINT WHERE YOU SUSPECT COULD POSSIBLY LEAK ENGINE SPEEDS UP THAT'S IT WORTH A SHOT BEFORE SPENDING MORE CASH
1helpful
1answer

Please Help... p0404 and p0137 Error Codes (1999 Saturn SL1)

yes egr valve is a common thing on this saturn. very pricy and yes you need the rear o2 sensor good luck i have a used egr if interested off a sl2
Not finding what you are looking for?

3,060 views

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Saturn Experts

ZJ Limited
ZJ Limited

Level 3 Expert

17989 Answers

Thomas Perkins
Thomas Perkins

Level 3 Expert

15088 Answers

john h

Level 3 Expert

29494 Answers

Are you a Saturn Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...