2006 BMW 5 Series Logo
Posted on Sep 13, 2011
Answered by a Fixya Expert

Trustworthy Expert Solutions

At Fixya.com, our trusted experts are meticulously vetted and possess extensive experience in their respective fields. Backed by a community of knowledgeable professionals, our platform ensures that the solutions provided are thoroughly researched and validated.

View Our Top Experts

I have been told I need a new starter. How much should that cost?

1 Answer

Anonymous

Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Vice President:

An expert whose answer got voted for 100 times.

  • Expert 437 Answers
  • Posted on Sep 14, 2011
Anonymous
Expert
Level 2:

An expert who has achieved level 2 by getting 100 points

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Vice President:

An expert whose answer got voted for 100 times.

Joined: Aug 17, 2009
Answers
437
Questions
0
Helped
130698
Points
830

The Bosch starter will probably run about $150, or $250 from the BMW dealer. The cost, however, is not the part, but the installation labor. You did not mention which engine you have in your 5 series, but this is not an easy job on any of them, and on some it is downright ugly.
Whichever car you have, plan on spending at least $400 in labor. May be more.
What makes them think you need a new starter? It is HIGHLY unusual for a BMW starter to fail after 5 years. So unusual that my usual aftermarket parts supplier does not even list the starter for that car yet. Did something happen to the car that would damage it?
Make sure that someone is not diagnosing your problem as a bad starter when all that is wrong is that the anti-theft circuit has tripped, locking out the starter. After they spend $700 of your money replacing a starter and it still does not work, they will start looking elsewhere for the problem, and if that happens they will never tell you that it turned out that you did not need a starter!

Add Your Answer

×

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

0helpful
1answer

New starter fitted but still fails to start unless with push

A garage told you that it was the starter motor which was replaced.. and then suggested the ignition switch? That's not much of a garage..

Those symptoms are indicative of a solenoid/relay/switch fault. But how do you find out which? Though to be honest, ignition switch (key) failures are actually quite rare.

The truth is you can spend a lot of time and money replacing parts and finding that nothing cures the problem. You've already paid for a new starter which didn't cure the problem..

Seriously - give an auto electrician a call. Or a mobile mechanic. Let them identify the fault (and they usually do..). You'll get a lot of 'could be' advice which may cost you a lot in replacement parts and not fix things. Give an auto electrician or mobile mechanic a call.
0helpful
1answer

What can I do to cut cost on a starter generator control module ?

these are one unit. The starter and the alternator are one. System is stupid, i believe. But it is what it is. This is on the outside of the engine. You could replace it. $5700 seem really high to me, unless the part costs $5500. Look up the parts cost. Go to alldatadiy.com. Buy it for up to $30. alldata will tell you how to replace the part.
0helpful
1answer

The solenoid will not work, I had a friend tap it with a screwdriver and my car will now start. I took it to a mechanic who said I have to have a solenoid and starter motor installed as the solenoid alone...

A remanufactured starter would be your best bet because you have to pay the same labor to replace solenoid as you would entire starter and the starter will come with a warranty.The starter should cost between 120 and 170, and the labor should only be about 80 to 100 dollars. Good luck
1helpful
1answer

I asked about getting a new starter for my 97 accord.

Remanufactured (Rebuilt) costs $159.00 plus $35.00 core charge at most auto parts stores....so you got what it cost for a rebuilt starter.
4helpful
4answers

1995 Bonneville will not start. Battery is working, however car will not turn over. I do not belive it is the starter and was told it was the motor. Is this the same as engine and how much will this cost,...

You don't want it to be the motor/engine. Be sure the battery is good. Then go to the starter. IF it has been a very long time since it was started the starter may be a problem. After the starter is ruled out then and only then do you consider the motor. Hope it helps.
3helpful
1answer

1992 LS 400 Lexus. Car wouldn't start. New battery, thought was fuse problem, but no, towed in and mechanic says need new starter but starter under the engine block, will need new gasket for block after...

remove black plastic relay cover in plastic underhood fuse box and activate relay9006980.jpg with a very small screwdriver and ignition on. If starts, obviously the starter is fine, if not the starter is indeed bad and needs replacement so hold onto your ankles cuz it's gonna hurt.
1helpful
1answer

1987 F150 302 ci. EFI, Automatic, Was running good. Next morning NOTHING! Wouldn't start or crank over? Just clicking and buzzing, Headlights OKAY. Tried jump starting... NO GOOD. Took battery in... Was...

try over riding the starter relay on the fender ,it has one there right?. dont go to a mechanic yet. the engine aint seized. if it doesnt have this relay then i would get the alternator tested. if you want to test it yourself it can be costly for the right equip. autozone usually tests for free. i dont know were you live so if theres not an autozone. let me know if you cant get it tested.
4helpful
2answers

Car not starting and have new battery

You are quite welcome. That is what FixYa is all about. Helping poeple such as youself. Now that you have told me that tapping on the starter makes a difference, It is my opinion that you do indeed have a starter issue. You have 2 options: First, you could take the starter off, and replace the solenoid and replace the worn internal contacts. This is the lesser cost option. The contact wear issue is a very common failure; I change contacts in starters 2-3 times a week. The second option is to replace the starter. If you want to go the contacts route, post back to me for detailed information.
0helpful
1answer

Starter problem

no. need to buy a new starter. get a chiltons or haynes manual for your vehicle. it will tell you every step to fixing any problem with your vehicle. found at any parts store
Not finding what you are looking for?

819 views

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top BMW Experts

vince

Level 3 Expert

2530 Answers

Steve Sweetleaf
Steve Sweetleaf

Level 3 Expert

1212 Answers

old marine
old marine

Level 3 Expert

2426 Answers

Are you a BMW Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...