Cars & Trucks Logo
Posted on Sep 04, 2011
Answered by a Fixya Expert

Trustworthy Expert Solutions

At Fixya.com, our trusted experts are meticulously vetted and possess extensive experience in their respective fields. Backed by a community of knowledgeable professionals, our platform ensures that the solutions provided are thoroughly researched and validated.

View Our Top Experts

This is my problem: yesterday, I had to have the alternator and battery replaced in my 2008 Solara convertible. I purchased the car new in May 2009 & it has 40,000 miles. I had the work done at Mieneke instead of my usual Toyota dealership, where I take the car for ALL scheduled maintenance, because I was stranded on Labor Day weekend (car would not start). Mieneke said a bad battery cell had caused the alternator to overwork & had probably been happening for over a month. My concern is that I'm having battery & alternator issues on a Toyota purchased new 2.5 years ago with only 40k miles. I also replaced the tires last month (during regular maintenance at the dealership) & was a little surprised the original tires that came on the vehicle needed replacing after only barely 2 years. I'm a single female car owner who is not a mechanic, so I need language to talk with the dealership and their service department about what I should be able to expect in an alternator & battery, whether this should be covered under warranty (I know I had the work done elsewhere & that invalidates it, but I was in a jam) & especially how I can get their attention to check my vehicle carefully during regular maintenance & make sure the system in a relatively new vehicle works as a high-end Toyota product should. If a bad battery cell was overworking the alternator (& creating a smell according to Mieneke) for over a month, shouldn't this have at least been detected during my maintenance checkup last month, where they told me I needed new tires? I'm sorry. This probably sounds crazy, but the whole point of my having a relationship with the dealership & keeping up regular maintenance should be to prevent getting stranded. I know no one can guarantee that will never happen, but an alternator & new battery at 40k? If you can just help give me some language to talk to with the dealership so I get adequate car care, I would appreciate it. Thanks.

1 Answer

Randy Ohler

Level 3:

An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

Superstar:

An expert that got 20 achievements.

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

  • Toyota Master 14,585 Answers
  • Posted on Sep 04, 2011
Randy Ohler
Toyota Master
Level 3:

An expert who has achieved level 3 by getting 1000 points

Superstar:

An expert that got 20 achievements.

All-Star:

An expert that got 10 achievements.

MVP:

An expert that got 5 achievements.

Joined: Jun 13, 2010
Answers
14585
Questions
8
Helped
3942475
Points
39683

Hey Lyn. Regular maintenance is a scheduled procedure recommended by the manufacturer. They don't check everything every time. If you would want them to do this and create a list of things checked , I am sure they might, but it will probably cost you more. People assume that because they take their cars to dealerships , that they get the best service available. This is not always true. If the battery and alternator are bad again, I would go back to mieneke and complain to them. they are nation wide and all of them should honor a warranty. What mieneke told you was probably opposite of what happened. The alternator was probably putting out to much of a charge and toasted the battery. Weak batteries wont kill an alternator. At least I have never seen or heard of it. As far as warranty issues, it is pretty much your responsibility to bring them up to the dealer. Again if there are specific things you want checked at maintenance time take a list and have them sign off on it. If they already have a list ask to see it and when there done ask for a copy. you pay for it, so they should give you one. I suggest that if you have an issue come up with repairs, to post on here and get some insight to what may be going on with your car. There are a lot of good mechanics on this site. Randy

Add Your Answer

×

Uploading: 0%

my-video-file.mp4

Complete. Click "Add" to insert your video. Add

×

Loading...
Loading...

Related Questions:

1helpful
1answer

When I connect the battery the blinkers come on constantly glowing, nothing else works, check the fuses, the alternator fuse is blown, replace that, connect the battery fuse blows again. 2007 solara.

Bad alternator or short in alternator wiring. You much need a wiring diagram. Is that the car? Was in an accident? You may have pinched wiring or a wire shorted to ground. Try new fuse with alternator disconnected, then with key on, connect alternator-watch for sparks, or clicks, -you might want to have the alternator tested, just to be sure. You have to start somewhere...
Maybe a wiring short in the blinker system? Or is the fuse blowing an alternator fuse?
0helpful
1answer

I have a 99 solara se. I have new battery and alternator but the car can't carry a load. Ac lights heater radio so forth

Not sure I follow your problem.
The alternator puts out 13-14 volts at idle but very few amps. If you turn on the headlights at idle the voltage may drop to 12 until you raise engine speed. The amperage goes up with engine speed.
Is the battery voltage at least 14 when the engine speed is 1500RPM or more ?
0helpful
1answer

2008 solara convertible radio cuts in and out

This is a well-known problem of Solara convertibles with JBL audio systems. Here's a link to the fix. I didn't need a ratchet - the bolts can be removed with a phillips head.

https://youtu.be/mgCtkK-UJPM
0helpful
2answers

2008 Camry Solara is having problems starting. It either hesitates or does not start at all. When it does start, it reset the clock and everything else.

recommend you have your battery terminals tested for corrosion,green yucky stuff on positive side of battery. also auto zone will check this for free. or advance auto your battery terminals {connections} may only need replacements. thank you for choosing fixya.com!!
0helpful
1answer

I recently purchase a 2008 PT Cruiser. The battery light came on while driving and the engine died. I managed to pull the cover to the shoulder of the road and it restarted. I was told it was a bad...

both battery terminals-- replace with full brass ones

alternator should have come first then battery

if a new alternator was fitted wont be the problem
if a refurbished/rebuilt alternator was fitted
they have a failure rate

whats left
could be a parasitic draw from the ignition or starter motor wirings
check 12 volts is getting from positive battery terminal to starter motor


replacing computer was a wasted brain frt idea




index-00nkgcv3qozdkgxfkoitxhz4-2-0.jpg
1helpful
1answer

1999 SOLARA V6 Starter

Consider trying with another battery. Possibly the battery is dying bcos the alternator is not charging up to rating.

Cheers.

rate this.
0helpful
1answer

Only during the quietest of times can I here the turn clicker.

spray foaming insulation they use on cracks in houses on the clicker
1helpful
1answer

Car won't start even after new battery purchase

Alternator problem, the alternator charges the battery when car is running, so it has probably died now. Was working at reduced capacity for a while, which is why you were only getting a partial charge for some time. Now you have an open circuit completely as alternator has failed completely, time for a visit to an auto electrician. PS replacing acid in battery with distilled water is not a good idea. It probably was time for a new battery anyway.
1helpful
1answer

Battery dying

No the alternator won't keep it running on a Toyota, the system is wired much different than most cars, found this out the hard way on same type of car. Test the alternator, raise the idle up to 1500 RPM turn on everything in the car, lites on high beam, ac blower on high, everything, voltage at battery should not be less than about 13.5 volts and not more than 14.7 volts, (clean battery cables first) if all that checks out you have a draw in the system, most common source is the glove box lite or trunk lite, on rare occasions a bad isolation diode in the alternator can cause a voltage draw, another test is to pull off the positive battery battery cable at night and lightly touch it to the battery post, if you see any faint spark there is a draw somewhere in the system, these types of issues can be heck to find, but not always, check what I said to. And last but not least clean the battery cables thoroughly, get a battery brush tool from parts store they are cheap, neutralize any acid with a solution of baking soda and warm tap water.
Not finding what you are looking for?

301 views

Ask a Question

Usually answered in minutes!

Top Toyota Experts

ZJ Limited
ZJ Limited

Level 3 Expert

17989 Answers

Ronny Bennett Sr.
Ronny Bennett Sr.

Level 3 Expert

6988 Answers

Thomas Perkins
Thomas Perkins

Level 3 Expert

15088 Answers

Are you a Toyota Expert? Answer questions, earn points and help others

Answer questions

Manuals & User Guides

Loading...